Verified Crisp requires 20+ critic reviews with 85%+ positive.
Crisp albums must have at least 60% positive critic reviews.
Spoiled albums have less than 60% positive critic reviews.
Listener Crisp albums have 3/5 or more stars.
Listener Spoiled albums have less then 3/5 stars.
Shake Appeal is Pitchfork news editor Evan Minsker’s ongoing survey of punk and garage rock records. As 2019 comes to a close, he shares his favorite 10 LPs and EPs in that vein, listed in alphabetical order.